2016 Cougar Football Recognition
| Courier News All-Area Offense | |
| 3rd Team KR/Athlete | Malachi Clemons |
| Courier News All-Area Defense | |
| 1st Team DL | Jared Reinson |
| 2nd Team – LB | Messiah Divine |
| 3rd Team – DB | Zach Masessa |
| All-Division Offense | |
| First-Team Offense | |
| Mike Patrizio | |
| Malachi Clemons | |
| Second-Team Offense | |
| Eric Lisanti | |
| Danny Young | |
| All-Division Defense | |
| First-Team Defense | |
| Jared Reinson | |
| Messiah Divine | |
| Second-Team Defense | |
| Zach Massesa | |
| Kyle Kuminski | |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Jake Schiavo | |
| NJFCA Super 100 team | |
| Jared Reinson | |
| Malachi Clemons |
