2012 Cougar Football Recognition
| Star Ledger | |
| All-Somerset Offense | |
| 1st team | Ryan Boyle |
| Chris Lee | |
| 2nd team | Sam Oltmans |
| 3rd team | Chris Chuganov |
| All-Somerset Defense | |
| 2nd team | Mike Boyer |
| Jake Colangelo | |
| Josh Reinson | |
| 3rd team | Nick Dameo |
| Kyle Merz | |
| All-Conference Offense | |
| 1st team | Ryan Boyle |
| Chris Lee | |
| 2nd team | Sam Oltmans |
| All-Conference Defense | |
| 1st team | Kyle Merz |
| Mike Boyer | |
| 2nd team | Jake Colangelo |
| Hanson Koota | |
| Nick Dameo | |
| All-Conference Honorable Mention: | |
| Josh Reinson, Ross Baginsky | |
| Erik Witten, Josh Lipowski, Chris Chugunov | |
| Courier News | |
| All-Area Defense | |
| 1st Team – | Mike Boyer |
| All-Area Offense | |
| 2nd Team – RB | Ryan Boyle |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Jake Colangelo, Chris Chugunov, Chris Lee, Kyle Merz, Sam Oltmans | |
| Princeton Packet | |
| Offense | |
| RB | Ryan Boyle |
| Receiver | Sam Oltmans |
| Line | Chris Lee |
| Defense | |
| Line | Mike Boyer |
| Line | Kyle Merz |
| Linebacker | Jake Colangelo |
| Back | Josh Reinson |
| Trenton Times | |
| 1st Team All-Area Offense | Chris Lee |
