2009 Cougar Football Recognition
| Star Ledger | |
| All-State Group 4 Offense | |
| 2nd Team | J.T. Tartacoff |
| 3rd Team | Kevin Azimi |
| All-Somerset Offense | |
| 1st Team | Kevin Azimi |
| 1st Team | J.T. Tartacoff |
| 2nd Team | DJ Ruhlman |
| 2nd Team | Taylor Mulligan |
| All-Somerset Defense | |
| 1st Team | Troy Gebhart |
| 2nd Team | Connor Oltmans |
| All-Conference Offense | |
| 1st Team – WR | J.T. Tartacoff |
| 1st Team – QB | DJ Ruhlman |
| 1st Team – RB | Kevin Azimi |
| 1st Team – TE | Taylor Mulligan |
| 1st Team – OL | Mike Woitach |
| 2nd Team – OL | Anthony Donadio |
| 2nd Team – OL | Kevin Lisanti |
| 2nd Team – WR | Mike Brown |
| All-Conference Defense | |
| 1st Team – DB | Connor Oltmans |
| 2nd Team – DL | Troy Gebhart |
| All-Conference Honorable Mention: | |
| Offensive Line | John Foley |
| Courier News | |
| All-Area Offense | |
| 1st Team – WR | J.T. Tartacoff |
| 2nd Team – RB | Kevin Azimi |
| 2nd Team – TE | Taylor Mulligan |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Troy Gebhart, Connor Oltmans, DJ Ruhlman, Mike Woitach | |
| Princeton Packet | |
|
Packet Player of the Year |
J.T. Tartacoff |
| Offense | QB – DJ Ruhlman |
|
RB- Kevin Azimi |
|
|
WR- J.T. Tartacoff |
|
| TE- Taylor Mulligan | |
|
|
|
| Defense | DB- Connor Oltmans |
| Trenton Times | |
| Offense | |
| 1st Team – RB | Kevin Azimi |
| 1st Team – WR | J.T. Tartacoff |
| 2nd Team – QB | DJ Ruhlman |
| 2nd Team – TE | Taylor Mulligan |
| 2nd Team – OL | Mike Woitach |
| Defense | |
| 2nd Team DB | Connor Oltmans |
- J.T. Tartacoff for being selected to the NJ Coaches Super 100 Senior Team.
- D.J. Ruhlman & Connor Oltmans for being selected to the NJ Coaches Super 100 Junior Team