2005 Cougar Football Recognition
| All-State Group 3 – Offense | |
| 3rd Team – Receiver | Steve Watson |
| All-Conference Offense | |
| 1st Team Offensive Line | Joe DiGangi |
| 1st Team Offense – Receiver | Steve Watson |
|
2nd Team Offense – QB:
|
Chris Fischer |
| 2nd Team Offense – Running Back | Will Treichler |
| 2nd Team Offensive Line | Kyle Passarelli |
| All-Conference Defense | |
| 1st Team Defensive Line | DJ Catalano |
| 1st Team Defensive Line | Pat McCoy |
| 1st Team Defensive Back | Dupree Wade |
| 2nd Team Defensive Line | Anthony Molesphini |
| 2nd Team Defensive Linebacker | Bryan Cummings |
| 2nd Team Defensive Back |
Scott Brady
|
| 2nd Team Defense – Punter | Gary Stefanski |
| All-Conference Honorable Mention: | |
| QB -Kevin Watson | WR-Mike Andrew |
| RB-Chris Garcia | LB-Alex Colarusso |
| Trenton Times | |
| All-Area Offense | |
| 2nd Team – Offensive Line | Joe DiGangi |
| 2nd Team – Wide Receiver | Steve Watson |
| 2nd Team – Kicker | Gary Stefanski |
| All-Area Defense | |
| 2nd Team – Defensive Line | Pat McCoy |
| 2nd Team – Defensive Back | Dupree Wade |
| Princeton Packet | |
| All-Packet Offense | |
| 1st Team – Offensive Line | DJ Catalano |
| 1st Team – Receiver | Steve Watson |
| All-Packet Defense | |
| 1st Team – Defensive Line | Pat McCoy |
| 1st Team – Defensive Back | Dupree Wade |
| Courier News | |
| All-Area Offense | |
| 2nd Team – Offensive Line | Joe DiGangi |
| 2nd Team – Wide Receiver | Steve Watson |
| 3rd Team – Offensive Line | DJ Catalano |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Chris Fischer (QB) | Pat McCoy (DL) |
| Kyle Passarelli (OL) | Gary Stefanski (K) |
| Will Treichler (RB) | Dupree Wade (DB) |
| Star Ledger | |
| All-Somerset Offense | |
| 1st Team Offensive Line | Joe DiGangi |
| 1st Team Offense – Receiver | Steve Watson |
| 3rd Team Offense – Running Back | Will Treichler |
| All-Somerset Defense | |
| 2nd Team Defensive Line | DJ Catalano |
| 3rd Team Defensive Line | Pat McCoy |