2004 Cougar Football Recognition
| Star Ledger | ||
| All-State Team: | ||
| 3rd Team – Chris Kondorossy, OL | ||
| Group 3 All-State Team | ||
| 1st Team – Chris Kondorossy, OL | ||
| Somerset All-County Offense | ||
| 1st Team – Chris Kondorossy, OL | ||
| 2nd Team – Chris Hyncik, OL | ||
| 3rd Team – Chris Minck, K | ||
| 3rd Team – Chris Fischer, QB | ||
| Somerset All-County Defense | ||
| 1st Team – Nick Umar, LB | ||
| 3rd Team – Ryan Andrew, CB | ||
| 3rd Team – Joe DiGangi, DL | ||
| All Conference Team | ||
| First Team – Offense | ||
| Nick Umar | Chris Hyncik | Chris Mink |
| First Team – Defense | ||
| Chris Kondorossy | Mark Hughes | Fred Ammons |
| Ryan Andrew | ||
| Second Team – Offense | ||
| Chris Fischer | Dupree Wade | Brett Mahoney |
| Jacob Welch | Kyle Passarelli | |
| Second Team – Defense | ||
| Joe DiGangi | Kennin Miller | |
| Honorable Mention | ||
| Dan Tully | Bryan Cummings | Steve Watson |
| DJ Catalano | ||
| Courier News | ||
| First Team – Offense | Chris Kondorossy | |
| Second Team – Defense | Nick Umar | |
| Third Team – Offense | Chris Mink | |
| Honorable Mention | Fred Ammons | Joe DiGangi |
| Chris Fischer | Mark Hughes | Chris Hyncik |
| Kennin Miller | Dupree Wade | |
| Princeton Packet | ||
| Offense | ||
| Nick Umar | Dupree Wade | Chris Hyncik |
| Chris Kondorossy | Chris Mink | |
| Defense | ||
| Ryan Andrew | ||
| Coach of the Year | Zoran Milich | |
| Trenton Times | ||
| All-Area Offense | ||
| 2nd Team – Offensive Line | Chris Hyncik | |
| All-Area Defense | ||
| 1st Team – Defensive Line | Chris Kondorossy | |
| 1st Team – Linebacker | Nick Umar | |
| 2nd Team – Defensive Back | Ryan Andrew | |
| All-Suburban Offense | ||
| 1st Team – Offensive Line | Chris Hyncik | |
| 1st Team – Kicker | Chris Minck | |
| Honorable Mention – Wide Receiver | Brett Mahoney | |
| Coach of the Year | Zoran Milich | |
| All-Suburban Defense | ||
| 1st Team – Defensive Line | Chris Kondorossy | |
| 1st Team – Linebacker | Nick Umar | |
| 1st Team – Defensive Back | Ryan Andrew | |
| Honorable Mention – Defensive Back | Fred Ammons |